Consider the following statements:

- Some books are files
- Some registers are files
- Some guides are books

Based on these statements, evaluate the following conclusions:

I. Some guides are registers is definitely true

II. No file is guide is a possibility

Choose the correct option based on the conclusions that logically follow from the statements.

Question

Consider the following statements:

- Some books are files
- Some registers are files
- Some guides are books

Based on these statements, evaluate the following conclusions:

I. Some guides are registers is definitely true

II. No file is guide is a possibility

Choose the correct option based on the conclusions that logically follow from the statements.

Accepted Answer

**Solution:**

1. Analyze the statements:
   - Some books are files
   - Some registers are files
   - Some guides are books

2. Examine Conclusion I: "Some guides are registers is definitely true"
   - From the statements, guides are related to books, and books are related to files.
   - Registers are related to files.
   - However, there is no direct or indirect information linking guides and registers.
   - Therefore, we cannot definitely conclude that some guides are registers.

3. Examine Conclusion II: "No file is guide is a possibility"
   - Since some guides are books and some books are files, it is possible that no file is a guide because the statements do not confirm any overlap between files and guides.
   - Hence, this conclusion is possible.

**Answer:** (b) If only conclusion II follows

Answer

Answer

Answer

Answer