Read the passage below carefully and answer the question that follows: India is not a signatory to the United Nations Refugee Convention; therefore, i...

Question

Read the passage below carefully and answer the question that follows:

India is not a signatory to the United Nations Refugee Convention; therefore, it is not obligated to provide asylum to people fleeing persecution in other countries. The government has not initiated any discussion on joining the UN Refugee Convention, which would have been a logical step if it intended to develop a humanitarian refugee policy. Moreover, while refugee protection provisions generally apply to all minorities escaping humanitarian crises, this bill offers citizenship based on religious preferences. If passed as is, the bill favors Hindu refugees over Muslim refugees migrating to India, which contradicts the secular nature of the Indian Constitution as stated in its preamble. The refugees who stand to benefit from this policy live in extreme poverty with inadequate sanitation and infrastructure.

Which of the following statements best continues the theme of the passage?

Options

A.

(a) A closer look at the provisions indicates that the current government is attempting to increase its Hindu voter count.

B.

(b) The government, instead of adopting a universal policy, has turned this into a communal issue with a hidden political motive, which undermines the purported humanitarian objective of the bill.

C.

(c) The bill at first glance appears to be a humanitarian effort to assist persecuted minorities but actually only aids Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis, and Christians from neighboring Muslim-majority countries.

D.

(d) This policy contradicts the principles of secularism and pluralism in India and is therefore unconstitutional.

citizenship amendment billrefugee policysecularismindian constitutionpolitical agenda

Solve This Question

Get instant feedback with detailed step-by-step solution

Start Solving →